Pizza is one of the most universally loved foods, but the cost of a pizza pie can vary greatly depending on where you buy it. From artisanal pies at famous pizzerias to casual chains like Domino’s and Papa John’s, we’ll explore the price ranges of pizza pies, using real-world examples, including places reviewed by Dave Portnoy, local spots, and chain restaurants.
Factors Influencing Pizza Prices
- Type of Pizzeria: Gourmet, local, or chain restaurant.
- Toppings: Basic cheese vs. loaded specialty toppings.
- Size: Small, medium, large, or extra-large pies.
- Location: Prices differ by region and city.
Average Pizza Costs by Type of Pizzeria
Pizzeria Type |
Average Cost (Cheese Pie) |
Description |
|---|---|---|
Top-Rated Pizzerias |
$18 – $35 |
Places highly rated by food critics. |
Casual Restaurants |
$12 – $20 |
Family-style restaurants or diners. |
Fast Food Chains |
$8 – $15 |
Domino’s, Papa John’s, Little Caesars. |
Local Pizzerias |
$10 – $18 |
Independent, neighborhood pizzerias. |
Examples: Dave Portnoy’s Top-Rated Pizzerias
Pizzeria (City) |
Cheese Pizza Cost |
Specialty Pies Cost |
Portnoy Score |
|---|---|---|---|
Di Fara Pizza (NYC) |
$30 |
$35+ (Toppings) |
9.4 |
Modern Apizza (CT) |
$19 |
$25 – $30 (White Clam) |
8.8 |
Sally’s Apizza (CT) |
$22 |
$27 – $32 (Special Pies) |
9.2 |
Pizzeria Bianco (AZ) |
$20 |
$25 – $30 (Wood-fired Pies) |
9.1 |
Fast Food Chains Pricing
Chain |
Cheese Pizza Cost |
Specialty Pies Cost |
Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
Domino’s |
$8 – $12 |
$14 – $18 |
Frequent deals like “Mix & Match” offers. |
Papa John’s |
$9 – $13 |
$15 – $18 |
Loyalty rewards for frequent orders. |
Little Caesars |
$6 – $8 |
$9 – $13 |
$6 Hot-N-Ready is budget-friendly. |
Pizza Hut |
$10 – $12 |
$14 – $17 |
Pan pizzas slightly more expensive. |
Local Pizzerias Pricing
Pizzeria Type |
Cheese Pizza Cost |
Specialty Pies Cost |
Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
Neighborhood Spot |
$12 – $15 |
$15 – $22 |
Often uses fresh, local ingredients. |
Popular Tourist Spot |
$16 – $20 |
$20 – $30 |
May include a premium for location. |
Comparing Costs by Pizza Size
Size |
Average Cost (Cheese) |
Specialty Toppings Avg. Cost |
|---|---|---|
Small (10-12″) |
$8 – $12 |
$12 – $18 |
Medium (12-14″) |
$12 – $16 |
$16 – $22 |
Large (14-16″) |
$15 – $20 |
$20 – $25 |
Extra Large (16-18″) |
$18 – $25 |
$25 – $35 |
Tips for Getting the Best Pizza Value
- Look for Specials: Many chains and local spots offer discounts on certain days.
- Go Local: Neighborhood pizzerias often have better quality for a similar price.
- Share a Pie: Splitting a large pizza is cost-effective for groups.
- Toppings Matter: Opt for fewer premium toppings to keep costs down.
- Check Reviews: Highly-rated spots may be worth the splurge for taste.
Sample Scenarios
Scenario |
Estimated Cost |
Breakdown |
|---|---|---|
Local Spot Night Out |
$16 |
Large cheese pizza ($14) + tax/tip ($2). |
Domino’s Family Night |
$25 |
Two medium pies with a deal. |
Gourmet Pizza Date |
$50 |
Specialty pie ($25) + drinks/appetizers. |
Tourist Pizzeria Visit |
$35 |
Cheese pizza ($20) + tourist markup/tip. |
Conclusion
The cost of a pizza pie ranges from $6 for a basic fast-food pizza to $35+ for gourmet pies at famous pizzerias. For the best value, explore local spots or take advantage of chain discounts. Whether you’re indulging in a high-end experience or enjoying a quick takeout meal, pizza is always a winning choice.